Choosing the right dog crate for crate training a puppy can make all the difference in establishing good habits and ensuring comfort. The Donoro Dog Crates stands out as the best overall for its sturdy construction and ease of use, while the Amazon Basics Foldable Metal Wire Crate offers excellent value with its foldability and removable tray. The main tradeoffs revolve around size, portability, and durability—larger crates suit bigger puppies but may be less convenient for small spaces, while foldable options are easier to store but might compromise on sturdiness. Keep reading for a detailed comparison to find the best fit for your puppy’s training needs.
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- Top-performing crates combine durability with easy cleaning features like removable trays.
- Size and weight are key; larger crates provide room for growth but can be cumbersome for small spaces.
- Foldable and stackable designs offer portability but may trade off some structural stability.
- Double-door models improve accessibility, especially in tight spaces or for quick access.
- Price often correlates with build quality—more expensive options tend to last longer and offer better safety features.
| dog crate for crate training puppy | Material | Size | Includes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Donoro Dog Crates for Small Do | Metal wire | 24" L x 18" W x 20" H | Dog crate, cover, handle, leak-proof tray |
| Amazon Basics Foldable Metal W | Metal wire | — | Removable plastic tray, divider panel |
| MidWest Homes for Pets 24-Inch | Metal wire | — | Leak-proof tray, divider panel, carry handle |
| Sweetcrispy 24 Inch Single Doo | Iron | 24 Inch | — |
| Oranland 48 inch Wire Dog Crat | Metal with rust-resistant finish | 48 inches | Washable trays, pre-assembled parts |
| BestPet 18-inch Foldable Metal | Metal | 18 inches | — |
| FDW 24-Inch Dog Crate for Smal | High tensile-strength wire with epoxy coating | — | — |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Donoro Dog Crates for Small Dogs, Indoor Double Door Metal Kennel, Collapsible, Brown, 24″L x 18″W x 20″H
This small-sized crate excels in versatility thanks to its double doors and collapsible design, making it easy to access and store. Compared with the Amazon Basics Foldable Metal Wire Small Dog Crate, it offers similar foldability but stands out with its included waterproof cover, which provides extra protection during indoor training. Its sturdy metal construction ensures safety for small puppies and cats, though its weight can make handling cumbersome once assembled. The waterproof cover and leak-proof tray add convenience, but the cover requires hand washing, which could be inconvenient for frequent cleaning. Overall, this crate is ideal for owners needing a durable, multi-purpose option that can be stored away when not in use.Pros:- Durable metal construction enhances safety
- Double doors facilitate easy entry and cleaning
- Includes waterproof cover and leak-proof tray for convenience
Cons:- Heavy to move when assembled
- Limited to small-sized dogs and cats
- Cover requires hand washing
Best for: Owners of small dogs or cats who want a durable, space-saving crate with easy access and coverage for indoor use.
Not ideal for: Pet owners with frequent need to move the crate over long distances or those with very small storage space, due to its weight and bulk.
- Size:24″ L x 18″ W x 20″ H
- Color:Brown
- Material:Metal wire
- Includes:Dog crate, cover, handle, leak-proof tray
- Warranty:1 year
Our verdict“This crate suits owners seeking a sturdy, versatile indoor solution for small pets that can be easily stored away.”
Amazon Basics Foldable Metal Wire Small Dog Crate with Removable Tray, Divider, Single Door, 24 x 18 x 20 inches, Black
This crate is a practical choice for small dog owners who prioritize portability and ease of cleaning, thanks to its foldable design and removable tray. Compared with the Sweetcrispy 24 Inch Single Door Dog Crate, it offers similar foldability but adds a divider for adjustable space, making it suitable for growing puppies. Its secure locking mechanism keeps pets safe, but proper locking is essential to prevent escapes. The lightweight metal frame makes it easy to transport, yet it’s best suited for small breeds under 20 pounds. This pick makes the most sense for owners who need a crate that can be easily stored in tight spaces or taken on-the-go, though it may be too small for slightly larger small dogs.Pros:- Folds flat for effortless transport and storage
- Removable tray simplifies cleaning
- Includes divider for adjustable internal space
Cons:- May be too small for larger small breeds
- Proper locking is critical for safety
- Limited to small dog sizes
Best for: Pet owners needing a portable, easy-to-clean crate for small breeds, especially for travel or frequent indoor storage.
Not ideal for: Owners of active or escape-prone small dogs who may push or chew at the locking mechanism, or those with larger small breeds over 20 pounds.
- Dimensions:24 x 18 x 20 inches
- Material:Metal wire
- Color:Black
- Door:Single door
- Includes:Removable plastic tray, divider panel
- Weight Capacity:Suitable for dogs under 20 x 15.25 inches
Our verdict“This crate is best for owners needing a lightweight, foldable option that adapts to a growing puppy or for travel purposes.”
MidWest Homes for Pets 24-Inch iCrate for Small Breeds, 12-20 lbs
Designed for small breeds, the MidWest iCrate offers a sturdy, rust-resistant build with an adjustable divider, making it ideal for crate training puppies up to 20 pounds. Compared with the Sweetcrispy 24 Inch Single Door Dog Crate, it provides a more secure latch system and a more durable finish, though it lacks foldability. Its easy assembly without tools and the inclusion of a divider panel support a growing puppy’s needs, but the crate’s limited color options and size may not suit slightly larger or more active puppies. This crate is perfect for owners seeking a safe and adjustable environment that grows with their puppy and prioritizes security over portability.Pros:- Rust-resistant, durable metal construction
- Includes adjustable divider for growth
- Easy to assemble without tools
- Secure latch system enhances safety
Cons:- May be too small for near-20-pound dogs
- Limited color options
- Not designed for frequent mobility
Best for: Puppy owners who want a durable, adjustable crate that will grow with their small dog during the training phase.
Not ideal for: Pet owners who need a portable or space-saving crate, or those with larger or highly active puppies prone to escape attempts.
- Dimensions:24.5 x 17.5 x 19.5 inches
- Weight Capacity:12-20 lbs
- Material:Metal wire
- Finish:Black e-coat
- Includes:Leak-proof tray, divider panel, carry handle
Our verdict“This crate suits owners wanting a long-lasting, safe environment for small puppies during crate training, with the flexibility to adjust size as they grow.”
Sweetcrispy 24 Inch Single Door Dog Crate, Metal Pet Kennel with Secure Lock, Foldable Design, Removable Tray for Easy Cleaning, Portable Puppy Cage for Small Dogs
Combining affordability with ease of use, the Sweetcrispy 24 Inch crate offers a sturdy metal frame with a secure lock and foldable design, making it practical for both indoor training and travel. When compared to the Donoro Dog Crates for Small Dogs, it provides a similar size but prioritizes portability with its foldable feature, though its simpler design means fewer added accessories like covers. Its removable tray simplifies cleaning and the secure lock enhances safety, but it’s limited to small dogs and may be less durable over long-term use. This crate makes sense for budget-conscious owners who want a reliable, portable training tool for small puppies, but it might not withstand active or larger dogs.Pros:- Sturdy metal construction
- Foldable for easy storage and transport
- Removable tray for simple cleaning
- Secure lock for safety
Cons:- Limited to small dog breeds
- Less durable for heavy or active puppies
- Limited color options
Best for: Owners of small puppies seeking an affordable, portable crate suitable for indoor training and occasional travel.
Not ideal for: Owners with larger dogs, or those needing a heavy-duty, long-term crate that can handle active or escape-prone puppies.
- Size:24 Inch
- Material:Iron
- Door:Single door
- Included Components:Removable tray, lock
- Warranty:1 year
Our verdict“This crate is best for owners on a budget who need a portable, easy-to-clean solution for small puppy crate training.”
Oranland 48 inch Wire Dog Crate with Divider, Stackable, Heavy Duty, Removable Tray
While primarily designed for larger or multiple dogs, the Oranland 48-inch crate offers unmatched durability and flexibility for multi-dog households or growing puppies. Its heavy-duty, rust-resistant construction and stackable design set it apart from smaller, single-purpose crates like the MidWest iCrate. The removable divider allows for versatile sizing, making it adaptable as your puppy matures or as you house multiple small dogs. Still, its size and weight make it unsuitable for frequent movement or smaller spaces. This crate is ideal for owners needing a robust, long-term solution for multiple or large puppies, even if it’s overkill for small, crate-trained puppies.Pros:- Heavy-duty, rust-resistant frame
- Stackable with other crates for space efficiency
- Removable divider for flexibility
- Easy to clean with washable trays
Cons:- Heavy and bulky to move without wheels
- Initial setup involves attaching wheels and screws
- May be excessive for small, crate-trained puppies
Best for: Owners with large, active puppies or multiple small dogs needing a durable, secure, and space-efficient crate setup.
Not ideal for: Owners with limited space or those seeking a lightweight, portable crate for small puppies or frequent moving.
- Size:48 inches
- Material:Metal with rust-resistant finish
- Features:Stackable, removable divider
- Includes:Washable trays, pre-assembled parts
- Construction:Reinforced frame
Our verdict“This crate suits owners who need a long-lasting, multi-purpose home for large or multiple puppies, despite its size and weight limitations for casual use.”
BestPet 18-inch Foldable Metal Dog Crate, Black, with Single Door and Leakproof Tray
This BestPet 18-inch crate stands out for its portability and sturdy build, making it an excellent choice for travel and quick indoor setups. Its foldable design and leakproof tray simplify transport and cleaning, especially compared to bulkier options like the FDW 24-Inch Dog Crate. However, its compact size limits growth, so it’s better suited for very small or young puppies rather than larger small breeds. The reinforced steel and secure latches provide peace of mind, yet some users may find folding the crate slightly cumbersome. Overall, this crate works best for owners needing a lightweight, space-saving option for small puppies or travel scenarios.
Pros:- Compact and lightweight, perfect for travel
- Foldable design for easy storage and transport
- Leakproof tray simplifies cleaning
- Secure slide-bolt latches keep puppy safe
Cons:- Limited to small breeds, not suitable for larger puppies
- Potentially cumbersome folding process for some users
- Only 18-inch size, restricting growth
Best for: Small breed puppy owners who prioritize portability and easy cleaning for indoor or travel use
Not ideal for: Pet owners with growing puppies or those needing a larger, more spacious crate for extended training periods
- Brand:BestPet
- Size:18 inches
- Color:Black
- Material:Metal
- Features:Foldable, Leakproof Tray, Single Door, Secure Latches
- Intended Use:Indoor, Outdoor, Travel
- Breed Recommendation:Small Breeds
- Warranty:90 days
Our verdict“This crate is ideal for owners seeking a portable, space-efficient solution for very small puppies or travel needs.”
FDW 24-Inch Dog Crate for Small Dogs, Double Door Folding Metal Wire Pet Kennel with Divider Panel & Leak-Proof Plastic Tray, Black
The FDW 24-Inch crate offers more room than the BestPet 18-inch, making it better suited for small dogs that are still growing or require a bit more space during crate training. Its double doors and divider panel provide flexible access and customization, setting it apart from single-door models. Made of durable, rust-resistant wire, it holds up well over time, especially compared to more fragile plastic options. However, the larger size may be unwieldy for owners with limited space, and assembly instructions are not explicitly provided, which could pose challenges. This pick is most appropriate for pet owners who want a long-lasting, adaptable crate that can accommodate a small dog’s growth.
Pros:- Larger space suitable for growing puppies
- Double doors for easier access from multiple angles
- Includes a divider panel to adjust space as puppy grows
- Rust-resistant, durable construction
Cons:- May be too large for owners with tight space constraints
- Assembly instructions are not detailed
- Limited color options, only black
Best for: Pet owners with small dogs that are still growing or need a versatile crate with multiple access points
Not ideal for: Owners with very limited space or those who prefer lightweight, collapsible options for frequent travel
- Material:High tensile-strength wire with epoxy coating
- Dimensions:24 inches
- Doors:Two large doors (front and side)
- Tray:Leak-proof ABS composite tray
- Folded Size:Less than 3 inches thick
- Features:Divider panel, foldable, portable with handle
Our verdict“This crate is best for owners seeking a durable, adjustable solution that lasts through puppy growth phases and offers flexible access.”
How We Picked
These products were evaluated based on durability, ease of cleaning, size options, safety features, and overall usability. We prioritized crates that are sturdy enough to withstand a puppy’s chewing and active behavior, while also being easy to assemble and clean. Portability and versatility played a role, especially for owners who need to store or transport the crate frequently. The ranking reflects a balance between quality and value, ensuring each option serves different needs—from beginners to experienced pet owners looking for long-term solutions.| dog crate for crate training puppy | Material | Includes |
|---|---|---|
| Donoro Dog Crates for Small Do | Metal wire | Dog crate, cover, handle, leak-proof tray |
| Amazon Basics Foldable Metal W | Metal wire | Removable plastic tray, divider panel |
| MidWest Homes for Pets 24-Inch | Metal wire | Leak-proof tray, divider panel, carry handle |
| Sweetcrispy 24 Inch Single Doo | Iron | — |
| Oranland 48 inch Wire Dog Crat | Metal with rust-resistant finish | Washable trays, pre-assembled parts |
| BestPet 18-inch Foldable Metal | Metal | — |
| FDW 24-Inch Dog Crate for Smal | High tensile-strength wire with epoxy coating | — |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Dog Crate For Crate Training Puppy
Selecting the perfect crate for puppy training involves more than just picking the right size. Consider the crate’s material—metal crates tend to be more durable, but plastic options can be more portable. Size is critical; a crate should be large enough for your puppy to stand, turn around, and lie down comfortably but not so large that they can use one corner as a bathroom. Ease of cleaning is another factor—removable trays simplify hygiene routines. Portability matters if you plan to travel or move the crate frequently, and safety features like secure locks can prevent escapes. Balancing these factors according to your specific needs will ensure a successful crate training experience.Size and Space Requirements
Choosing the right size of crate is essential for effective crate training. A crate that’s too large can encourage your puppy to eliminate in one corner while sleeping in another, hindering housebreaking efforts. Conversely, a crate that’s too small will make your puppy uncomfortable and may cause anxiety. It’s best to select a crate that allows your puppy to stand up, turn around, and stretch out comfortably. Consider the expected growth of your puppy—some crates come with dividers to adapt as they grow, making them a practical long-term investment.
Material and Durability
The material impacts both durability and safety. Metal wire crates are generally sturdier and well-ventilated, reducing overheating and allowing you to monitor your puppy easily. Plastic crates can provide a cozy, den-like environment, but they may not be as resistant to chewing or rough handling. For puppies prone to chewing or those with a tendency to escape, reinforced metal models are often better. Think about your puppy’s behavior and your living environment when choosing material—higher durability often justifies a higher price but can extend the crate’s lifespan.
Ease of Cleaning
Crates with removable trays or easy-to-clean surfaces simplify maintenance, especially during house training when accidents are common. Metal crates with slide-out trays reduce the hassle of deep cleaning and help keep your home hygienic. Avoid models with complicated assembly or hard-to-reach corners, as these can become breeding grounds for bacteria and odors. Remember, a clean crate encourages your puppy to see the space as a safe and comfortable zone, reinforcing positive training outcomes.
Portability and Storage
If you need to move or store the crate frequently, look for foldable or stackable designs. Collapsible crates are convenient for traveling or small living spaces, but they sometimes sacrifice some stability. Heavy-duty crates with a sturdy frame are better suited for long-term use in one location. Consider where you’ll place the crate and whether you’ll need to transport it—this choice impacts both functionality and your budget. Be aware that more portable options might be less durable over time, especially if your puppy is very active.
Safety and Security Features
Safety is paramount—double-locking doors, secure latches, and non-toxic finishes prevent escapes and injuries. Some crates come with additional safety features like rounded edges or reinforced corners that protect your puppy from injury. Avoid models with flimsy locks or sharp edges, as these can compromise your puppy’s safety. Investing in a well-constructed crate not only ensures your puppy’s security but also builds confidence in their training process.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use a crate that’s slightly bigger for my puppy’s crate training?
Using a slightly larger crate is generally acceptable, especially if your puppy is still growing, but it’s important to avoid excessive space. A crate that’s too big can encourage your puppy to eliminate in one corner and sleep in another, which slows housebreaking. To mitigate this, some crates include dividers that allow you to adjust the space as your puppy grows, ensuring the crate remains a cozy, den-like environment that promotes good habits and comfort.
Is a metal wire crate better than a plastic one for crate training?
Metal wire crates are often preferred for crate training because they are durable, well-ventilated, and allow for better supervision. They also tend to be more resistant to chewing, which is common among puppies. Plastic crates might be more cozy and less intimidating for some dogs but can be less sturdy and harder to clean thoroughly. Your choice should depend on your puppy’s behavior and your preference for visibility and airflow in the crate.
How important are foldable features in a puppy crate?
Foldable crates are highly convenient if you plan to travel or need to store the crate when not in use. They make setup and breakdown quick and easier, especially in small spaces. However, some foldable models may compromise on sturdiness or security, so it’s vital to choose one with strong locking mechanisms and a durable frame. For permanent setups, a non-folding, heavier-duty crate might provide better longevity and safety.
Should I select a crate with a divider for my puppy?
Yes, a crate with a divider is a smart choice for puppy crate training because it allows you to adjust the space as your puppy grows. Using a divider helps prevent your puppy from using one corner as a bathroom while sleeping in another, reinforcing housetraining. It also makes the crate a more versatile, long-term solution, saving you money by avoiding the need to buy multiple crates as your puppy matures.
What features make a crate safer for a puppy?
Safe crates typically feature secure locking mechanisms, rounded or smooth edges, and non-toxic finishes. Avoid models with sharp corners or flimsy latches that can break or open unexpectedly. A well-ventilated design ensures good airflow, reducing the risk of overheating. Investing in a crate with these safety features provides peace of mind and helps establish a positive, secure environment for your puppy’s training.
Conclusion
For first-time puppy owners or those seeking a straightforward, reliable option, the Donoro Dog Crates offers excellent durability and ease of use. Budget-conscious shoppers will find the Amazon Basics Foldable Metal Wire Crate delivers great value with its portability and cleaning features. For larger or more active puppies, the Oranland 48 inch Wire Dog Crate provides heavy-duty construction and a divider for long-term use. Beginners and those with limited space should prioritize foldable models, while experienced owners looking for a sturdily built, secure crate may opt for premium options. Tailor your choice to your puppy’s size, temperament, and your living situation to ensure successful crate training.
