Choosing sustainable pet food in 2027 requires balancing environmental impact, nutritional quality, and your pet’s specific needs. Among the top contenders, Open Farm Ancient Grains Dry Dog Food with Wild-Caught Salmon stands out for its traceability and high-quality ingredients, making it ideal for conscientious dog owners who prioritize wild seafood and ancient grains. Open Farm Kind Earth Plant-Based Food offers a vegan alternative that’s hypoallergenic and digestible, suited for owners seeking plant-based diets for their pets. Meanwhile, Open Farm Grain-Free Wild Salmon Kibble delivers a protein-rich, grain-free option with wild-caught salmon, perfect for sensitive skin or stomach issues. Each option involves tradeoffs—such as higher cost, ingredient specifics, or dietary restrictions—so understanding what matters most to your pet and your values helps make the best choice.
Get pet supplies delivered free — and shop member deals
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Access to Prime Big Deal Days deals on October 6–7
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- Open Farm’s products prioritize traceability and wild-caught ingredients, appealing to eco-conscious pet owners.
- Plant-based options like Kind Earth provide hypoallergenic and sustainable diets but may lack some nutrients of animal-based foods.
- Grain-free formulas with wild salmon support sensitive pets and skin health, though they may be more expensive.
- Traceability and ingredient sourcing are key factors in choosing truly sustainable pet foods.
- Tradeoffs include potential higher costs, allergen considerations, and dietary suitability for your pet.
| Open Farm Ancient Grains Dry Dog Food with Wild-Caught Salmon, 4 lb |  | Best Overall for Traceability and Wild Ingredients | Brand: Open Farm | Flavor: Wild Salmon Ancient Grain | Life Stage: All life stages | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Open Farm Kind Earth Plant-Based Dry Dog Food, 20 lb |  | Best for Plant-Based, Hypoallergenic Diets | Brand: Open Farm | Diet type: Vegan | Food form: Pellet | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Open Farm Grain Free Dry Dog Food, Wild Caught Salmon Kibble, 4lb Bag |  | Best Grain-Free with Wild Salmon for Sensitive Pets | Brand: Open Farm | Flavor: Wild-Caught Salmon | Age Range: All Life Stages | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Open Farm RawMix Ancient Grains Wild Ocean Dry Dog Food, 3.5 lb |  | Best for Raw-Style, Multi-Fish Protein Diets | Brand: Open Farm | Flavor: Wild-Ocean Recipe | Weight: 3.5 lb | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| sustainable pet food | Brand | Flavor | Form | Weight |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Open Farm Ancient Grains Dry D | Open Farm | Wild Salmon Ancient Grain | Pellet | 4 pounds |
| Open Farm Kind Earth Plant-Bas | Open Farm | Plant | — | — |
| Open Farm Grain Free Dry Dog F | Open Farm | Wild-Caught Salmon | — | — |
| Open Farm RawMix Ancient Grain | Open Farm | Wild-Ocean Recipe | Pellet | 3.5 lb |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Open Farm Ancient Grains Dry Dog Food with Wild-Caught Salmon, 4 lb
This option stands out for its commitment to wild-caught salmon and ancient grains, offering a balanced diet with traceable ingredients. Compared with grain-free options, it provides a more traditional nutritional profile while avoiding legumes and potatoes, often scrutinized for environmental and health concerns. However, its inclusion of wheat might be unsuitable for dogs with allergies. This pick makes the most sense for owners who prioritize wild seafood and ingredient transparency, even if it comes with a higher price tag and potential allergen considerations.
Pros:- Made with wild-caught salmon and ancient grains
- Includes non-GMO fruits and vegetables, pumpkin, and coconut oil
- Traceable ingredients from specific geographic regions
Cons:- May contain wheat, which could be an allergen
- Relatively higher cost compared to conventional dog foods
Best for: Pet owners seeking a balanced, traceable, and wild-caught protein source for their dogs.
Not ideal for: Owners looking for a completely grain-free or plant-based diet, or dogs with wheat allergies.
- Brand:Open Farm
- Flavor:Wild Salmon Ancient Grain
- Life Stage:All life stages
- Form:Pellet
- Weight:4 pounds
- Package Size:4 pounds
Our verdict“Ideal for owners prioritizing wild ingredients, traceability, and balanced nutrition, despite potential allergen concerns.”
Open Farm Kind Earth Plant-Based Dry Dog Food, 20 lb
This vegan formula is designed for all life stages, emphasizing hypoallergenic and digestible ingredients like pumpkin, turmeric, and coconut oil. It offers a compelling choice for owners committed to reducing animal product consumption while maintaining balanced nutrition. However, the product description’s mention of a different recipe can cause some confusion about the actual ingredients. Compared to meat-based options, it might lack some amino acids naturally found in animal proteins, requiring owners to consider their pet’s specific dietary needs. Still, this pick excels for those seeking a sustainable, plant-based alternative that supports immune and skin health.
Pros:- Complete and balanced vegan nutrition
- Suitable for all breed sizes and life stages
- Includes ingredients to support digestion, immunity, and skin health
Cons:- Ingredient info may be unclear due to description inconsistency
- Potentially higher cost than conventional diets
Best for: Owners seeking a vegan, hypoallergenic diet for their dogs without sacrificing nutritional completeness.
Not ideal for: Dogs with special protein requirements or those who prefer traditional meat-based diets.
- Brand:Open Farm
- Diet type:Vegan
- Food form:Pellet
- Flavor:Plant
- Bag size:20 lb
- Special ingredients:Pumpkin, turmeric, coconut oil, chicory root
Our verdict“Best suited for eco-conscious owners wanting a hypoallergenic, plant-based diet for their pets, with some nutritional caveats.”
Open Farm Grain Free Dry Dog Food, Wild Caught Salmon Kibble, 4lb Bag
This grain-free kibble features wild-caught Pacific salmon and non-GMO fruits and vegetables, making it a strong choice for pets with sensitivities to grains or legumes. Its high protein content and omega-3 fatty acids support skin, coat, and overall health, which is especially beneficial for dogs with sensitive stomachs or skin issues. However, the smaller 4-pound size may be limiting for larger or highly active dogs, and the premium ingredients come at a higher price point. Compared to the other options, it offers a straightforward, high-quality fish protein source with clear sustainability credentials.
Pros:- Grain-free with high-quality wild salmon
- Non-GMO fruits, veggies, and superfoods
- Supports skin, coat, and immune health
Cons:- Limited to 4 lb bag size, less suitable for large dogs
- Higher premium price
Best for: Pet owners with sensitive or allergy-prone dogs needing a grain-free, high-quality salmon diet.
Not ideal for: Large or energetic dogs requiring larger quantities or owners on a tighter budget.
- Brand:Open Farm
- Flavor:Wild-Caught Salmon
- Age Range:All Life Stages
- Item Form:Pellet
- Specific Uses:Sensitive Skin, Sensitive Stomach
- Package Size:4 lb
Our verdict“Excellent for owners of sensitive dogs seeking a high-quality, grain-free salmon diet, with cost and size as potential limitations.”
Open Farm RawMix Ancient Grains Wild Ocean Dry Dog Food, 3.5 lb
This product emphasizes a raw-inspired approach, combining multiple fish proteins like whitefish, salmon, and rockfish, plus freeze-dried raw chunks and bone broth coating. It appeals to owners who value meat sourcing from farms with animal welfare certification and want a diet that mimics raw feeding. While the ingredients are traceable, the lack of a detailed nutritional profile makes it harder to judge overall balance. This option is especially suited for medium and large breeds that thrive on diverse fish proteins and raw elements, but it may be less transparent in nutritional specifics.
Pros:- Includes multiple fish proteins and freeze-dried raw chunks
- Traceable ingredients sourced from certified farms
- Bone broth coating enhances palatability and nutrition
Cons:- Limited product info on exact nutritional breakdown
- Smaller size may be less suitable for big or active dogs
Best for: Owners seeking a multi-fish, raw-style diet with traceable ingredients for their medium or large dogs.
Not ideal for: Owners needing a full nutritional profile or feeding smaller breeds requiring less quantity.
- Brand:Open Farm
- Flavor:Wild-Ocean Recipe
- Weight:3.5 lb
- Form:Pellet
- Special Ingredients:Bone broth, freeze-dried raw chunks
- Target Species:Dog
Our verdict“Ideal for owners wanting a multi-fish, raw-style diet emphasizing traceability and animal welfare, with some nutritional transparency tradeoffs.”
How We Picked
Our selection process focused on sustainability factors such as ingredient traceability, sourcing from wild or responsibly farmed sources, and the environmental impact of production. We prioritized products that clearly disclose their ingredient origins, avoid unnecessary fillers, and use environmentally friendly practices. Nutritional completeness and suitability for all life stages were also considered, ensuring the options are not only sustainable but truly balanced for your pet. Finally, we examined tradeoffs like price, ingredient clarity, and dietary restrictions to recommend products that serve a variety of needs and values.
| sustainable pet food | Flavor | Special ingredients |
|---|---|---|
| Open Farm Ancient Grains Dry D | Wild Salmon Ancient Grain | — |
| Open Farm Kind Earth Plant-Bas | Plant | Pumpkin, turmeric, coconut oil, chicory root |
| Open Farm Grain Free Dry Dog F | Wild-Caught Salmon | — |
| Open Farm RawMix Ancient Grain | Wild-Ocean Recipe | Bone broth, freeze-dried raw chunks |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Sustainable Pet Food
Choosing the best sustainable pet food involves evaluating multiple factors: ingredient sourcing, environmental footprint, nutritional completeness, and your pet’s specific dietary needs. Sustainability isn’t just about ingredients but also about production practices and transparency. As you explore options, consider whether your priority is wild-caught seafood, plant-based diets, or responsibly farmed proteins. Size, budget, and dietary restrictions also influence the ideal choice, so I break down key considerations to help you decide.
Ingredient Sourcing and Traceability
Focus on products that specify where ingredients come from and how they are obtained. Wild-caught seafood, responsibly farmed fish, or organic plant ingredients tend to have a lower environmental impact. Traceability ensures accountability and allows you to verify sustainability claims. Look for brands that disclose lot numbers or geographic origins to confirm sourcing practices.
Environmental Impact
Consider how the ingredients are produced. Wild-caught seafood usually has a lower carbon footprint than farmed, but overfishing concerns may arise. Plant-based diets significantly reduce environmental impact but require careful formulation to meet all nutritional needs. Grain-free formulas often rely on fish or meat, which can be more resource-intensive. Balancing these factors depends on your values and your pet’s dietary requirements.
Nutritional Balance and Suitability
Your pet’s age, breed, and health status influence the best choice. Some animals thrive on plant-based diets, while others require animal proteins. Always check for complete and balanced claims, especially if opting for raw or specialized diets. Size and activity level also matter—larger or high-energy dogs might need larger quantities or more calorie-dense foods.
Cost and Size Considerations
Premium ingredients and sustainable sourcing often come with higher costs. Smaller bags may be suitable for trial or small breeds but can be expensive for larger or active dogs. Evaluate your budget and how much food your pet consumes to determine if a higher price is justified by quality and sustainability benefits.
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes pet food sustainable?
Sustainable pet food is produced using ingredients that are responsibly sourced, have a lower environmental impact, and often involve transparent supply chains. This includes wild-caught seafood managed for sustainability, responsibly farmed proteins, and plant-based ingredients cultivated with eco-friendly practices. Additionally, sustainable packaging and production methods contribute to the overall eco-friendliness of the product.
Are plant-based pet foods nutritionally complete?
Many plant-based pet foods are formulated to meet all nutritional requirements for dogs and cats, including essential amino acids, vitamins, and minerals. However, not all are created equal, so it’s important to choose those with verified nutritional labels and consult your veterinarian if your pet has special dietary needs. These diets are ideal for owners seeking lower-impact options, but some pets may require additional supplementation.
Is wild-caught seafood sustainable for pet food?
Wild-caught seafood can be sustainable if sourced from fisheries with strict management and quotas designed to prevent overfishing. Look for certifications and traceability data that confirm responsible harvesting practices. Choosing wild seafood over farmed options can reduce pollution and habitat destruction, but it’s vital to pick products with transparent sourcing to ensure sustainability claims are valid.
How do I know if a pet food is truly eco-friendly?
Check for clear disclosures about ingredient origins, third-party certifications, and company transparency. Brands that share detailed sourcing information, use eco-friendly packaging, and avoid unnecessary fillers are more likely to be genuinely sustainable. Reading ingredient labels and researching the company’s sustainability practices can help you make an informed choice.
Can sustainable pet foods be more expensive?
Yes, products with responsibly sourced ingredients, traceability, and eco-friendly packaging often come at a higher price point. The investment reflects the costs associated with sustainable farming, wild harvesting, and quality control. While this can be a barrier for some, many owners find the environmental benefits and potential health advantages justify the extra expense.
Conclusion
For pet owners prioritizing wild-caught ingredients and traceability, the Open Farm Ancient Grains with Wild Salmon offers a balanced choice. Those committed to vegan diets and hypoallergenic needs should consider the Kind Earth Plant-Based Food. Owners of sensitive or allergy-prone pets might find the Wild Salmon Grain-Free Kibble best, while those seeking a raw-style, multi-fish diet will appreciate the RawMix Ocean. Your decision should align with your pet’s dietary requirements, your sustainability values, and budget considerations, ensuring you choose a product that’s good for the planet and your pet’s health.
Halloween Picks
halloween
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
